Part 2: Ask Yourself: Rent or Buy? Can You Really Afford This House?

In my last post, we saw that owning a home is generally a good thing for individual finances in the long run, even if only slightly. As a homeowner myself, there is also the relative security of knowing my landlord won't up and sell my home out from under me or raise the rent! Though homeownership carries more responsibility, for myself, it just feels good to have my home be .... well, my home!

To be sure, the recession illustrates that renters need to consider not just their desires, but also their financial realities before purchasing a home. Buying a home is a big financial responsibility - the biggest one you will ever make - and one that protects you against those rent increases. A home represents stability, the place where you want to settle down for at least five to seven years and raise your family, if you are inclined. Bottom line: You don't want to take on more square footage than you can maintain and enjoy.

Still not sure? This simple online survey (www.bankrate.com/calculators/mortgages/rent-or-buy-home.aspx) can help and so can your financial planner.

And when you are ready, of course, seek me out, Your Personal Realtor!

www.car.org/newsstand/crem/current-issue thank you to Paula Hess, senior editor of California Real Estate Magazine.

Ask Yourself: Rent or Buy? Part 1

Sixty-five percent of Americans prefer owning a home versus renting. Is this just some leftover remnant of "the American dream?" Is it a romantic notion, or can it make financial sense, as well? Is the time right for your family?

With all of the foreclosures, fragile economy and fear about where to put one's investment dollars, the question about whether it is good for your pocketbook is more important than ever.

You've heard "there may never be a better time to buy," what with home prices and mortgage rates at near historic lows. But the reason to buy should have more to do with you and your family's situation than with the market. Yes, prices are low - really low, but tighter lending requirements have made it harder to qualify for a home loan. Bottom line: You'll need a larger down payment and a higher FICO score.

Interestingly, declining home prices have made the differential between buying and renting - significant in years past - minimal in some regions. However, with a cash downpayment, buyers may be able to save an average of $100 per month paying a mortgage over rent for a comparable property.

Of course, homeowners qualify for tax breaks, most notably the mortgage interest and property tax deductions. A general tax benefit-analysis reveals that a buyer purchasing a median-priced home with 20% down and a 30-year conventional mortgage looks to save over $500 per year on taxes. Not a huge amount to be sure, but homeowners will take it, along with the knowledge that their payments can be building equity and not just going into the pocket of a landlord!

In Part 2, we'll look at the second consideration: Can you really afford this house?

So, Should You Buy or Should You Rent?

Awhile back I posted a question on my Facebook page asking what the pros and cons were about buying a home and renting a home. Some of the pros of renting were that repairs would be made by the landlord and renters don't have to pay that dreaded property tax bill!

Some of the cons of renting: All landlords don't jump to make needed repairs and some tenants, afraid that their rent will be raised, won't ask! Also, you never know when you may have to move should the landlord need to sell his property.

Well, it turns out that financially speaking, the cost gap has narrowed. Affordable home prices and low interest rates have created an ideal time for many diehard renters to purchase homes, and now a new week-long look at homeownership confirms it.

A national study, conducted for The Associated Press, shows that the difference between monthly rents and mortgage payments is at its lowest level in nearly 20 years!

The analysis of 45 metro areas found the difference between the monthly mortgage payment on a median-priced home and the median rent has declined to $256. In some areas, the difference is as low as $100, according to the study. The last time the price gap was that close was in 1993, when it decreased to $264!

The study, conducted by Marcus & Milichap Real Estate Investment Services, used median prices for the last three months of 2009 and calculated mortgage payments by assuming a 10-percent down payment and a 30-year fixed loan at 5.07 percent. It also assumed borrowers paid for private mortgage insurance and didn’t include repair costs and tax benefits.

And don't forget, owning a home does have significant tax benefits, including deductions for those dreaded property taxes and loan interest. Homeowners also can enjoy building equity and creating a means of forced savings as they pay down the principal on the home.

If you are a renter and think you might want to wade in to a home purchase, you can prepare by ensuring your credit reports are up to date and save for a down payment of at least 20 percent, or at least enough to pay for your closing costs.

Although home buyers should not focus solely on future home price appreciation, according to data collected by the CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® (C.A.R.) over the last 40 years, homeowners who purchase a median-priced house, live in it for at least five years, and sell it at the then-current median price, have averaged an annual rate of return of more than 11 percent.

As a long-term homeowner, in my opinion, owning our home has rewards that far outweigh any cons. Planting a tree and knowing that more than likely we will be here to see it get bigger each year! Christmas dinners and our traditional Easter egg hunts. Yes, it is good, and Lord willing, will continue to be so.

Would You Rather Rent or Own?

And the survey says ...

Americans prefer homeownership!

A new national survey gauging attitudes toward housing finds 2/3 of Americans (65%) still prefer owning a home, despite the challenging economic environment and the housing downturn. The Fannie Mae National Housing Survey, conducted between December 2009 and January 2010, polled homeowners and renters to assess their confidence in homeownership as an investment, the current state of their household finances, views on the U.S. housing finance system, and overall confidence in the economy.

Being More Careful!

The survey did reveal that homeowners and renters alike are taking a more cautious approach to homeownership. Nearly a quarter of renters polled (23%) said they will buy a home later than once planned. In addition, Americans with traditional, fixed-rate mortgages with predictable payments are significantly more satisfied than those with other types of mortgages.

Why Do We Want To Own? Getting Rich Quick Days Are Over!
Respondents cited non-financial reasons such as safety (43%) and quality of local schools (33%) as driving factors in wanting to own a home, ahead of financial considerations.

Should You Walk Away If You Can't Make Your Payments?
Most respondents (88%) believe that walking away from an underwater mortgage is NOT acceptable, but those who know someone who has defaulted are more than twice as likely to have seriously considered stopping payments on their mortgage.

How about you? Would you rather own or rent, and why? And how do you feel about walking away from a mortgage you can no longer afford?